[YG Conlang Archives] > [romconlang group] > messages [Date Index] [Thread Index] >


[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next]

Re: [romconlang] Pronunciation of gu- (for Gmc w) in Romance?




Sorry for late response. I've been swamped in Real World
stuff.

Pedro Aguiar skrev:
> Interestingly, the same happened when Portuguese
> missionaries created the Lingua Franca in 16th-18th
> century Brazil. They found the /w/ semivowel in native
> Tupi language, but since it does not exist in Portuguese,
> the sound was written (and then pronounced) as /gw/ (like
> Wan�bara/Guanabara, warana/guaran�). Lately, ethnologues
> and linguists have tried to restore original pronunciation
> of Tupi with a more accurate writing standard, even
> suggesting new alphabets (though there's no universally
> accepted system yet).

In both late Latin and Portuguese the probable reason was
that the intervocalic allophone of /gw/, namely [Gw] was the
phoneetically closest thing to [w] found in the language.
Cf. the dialectal pronunciation of Spanish where _agua_ is
in fact ['awa]! It is not entirely clear where late Latin
had acquired intervocalic /gw/, since in classical Latin
/gw/ was found only in the combination /ngw/, but perhaps
original intervocalic _qu_ had already gone through > gw >
Gw > w in some areas/styles/contexts/words or -- most likely
-- in fast speech. However it is significant that Gothic
_wulfs_ simply became _ulfus_ in Latin (_Athaulfus_ <
_A�awulfs_ etc.)

> Notice difference with other native American languages
> like Quechua, where transliteration into Castillian led to
> /w/ written as "hu" (Tawantinsuyu/Tahuantinsuyu,
> Tiwanaku/Tihuanaco).
>

There was some precedence in Spanish spelling, with words
like _huevo_ which had acquired an _h_ to signal that the
_u_ should be pronounced [w] and not [v] in medieval
spelling/pronunciation. There were no parallel cases in
Portuguese, which hadn't gone through the O > uo > ue
sound change.
--

/BP 8^)
--
Benct Philip Jonsson
mailto:melrochX@hidden.email (delete X!)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"If a language is a dialect with an army and a navy,
of what language, pray, is Basque a dialect?" (R.A.B.)