[YG Conlang Archives] > [jboske group] > messages [Date Index] [Thread Index] >


[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next]

SL & the 2nd Excellent Solution



I have proposed:
> Kind:          lo broda                 le broda               la broda
> Kinds of:      PA lo broda              PA le broda            PA la broda
> % of Kinds of: piPA lo broda            piPA le broda          piPA la broda
> Bits of:       piPA (loi) (tu'o) broda  piPA lei (tu'o) broda  piPA lai broda
>                                         le piPA broda
> Countable:     PA (loi) (ro) broda      PA lei (ro) broda      PA la broda 
> % of countbls: piPA loi ro broda        piPA lei ro broda      
> Collective:    loi (ro) broda           lei (ro) broda         lai broda
> 
> {piPA le (tu'o) broda} would mean "some of a certain broda", while
> {le piPA broda} would mean "a certain bit of broda" 
> 
> "% of countables" = proportions of a population of countables -- e.g. 
> {piso'e loi ro prenu} = "most people"; {piso'e lo (ro) nanmu} = 
> "most kinds of men" 
> 
> {loi re prenu} = "a pair of people" 
> {lei re prenu} = "a certain pair of people". 
> {loi piso'e (loi ro) prenu} = {piso'e loi ro prenu} = "a majority of people"
> {lei piso'e (loi ro) prenu} = "a certain majority of people"

{loi piso'e (loi ro) prenu} = a majority as a collective
-- "loi piso'e prenu hold the power in the country"

{piso'e loi ro prenu} = a majority as individuals
-- "piso'e loi ro prenu enjoy football"

> {da poi broda} = {da broda} neutralizes the distinction between
> {da (poi) du pa broda} and {da (poi) du pisu'o broda} (and
> possibly {da (poi) du pa lo broda} 

****

This handles *everything* people have been asking for, with *no* new
gadri or LAhE. Plus it handles rather nicely a load of useful
extra stuff. SL currently handles approximately none of it.

Here is a list of main differences from SL:

* Default outer PA is mo'ezi'o. (Arguably consistent with usage.)

* in a lo/le/la description, broda means "is a kind of broda" not "is a
single broda". (Arguably consistent with usage.)

* Default gadri is loi, not lo. (Consistent with usage, given other
differences.)

* Default inner PA is tu'o/mo'ezi'o, except after PAloi. (About as
consistent with usage as SL is.)

* Inner PA after loi is not a pure cardinality (of the set of all
broda) but rather indicates the number of broda in the collective: loi 
re broda = a pair of broda, loi pimu broda = a group consisting of 1 in 
every 2 broda. (Not disruptive to usage.)

--And.