[YG Conlang Archives] > [engelang group] > messages [Date Index] [Thread Index] >
Mike S. scripsit:
Proper names are always definite except in special cases like "a John Smith"
> As far as how "m" and "d" interact: I don't know if "m" was intended to
> entail definiteness, though pragmatically at least that could be the usual
> interpretation. That entailment is certainly not necessary though; plenty
> of natlangs incl Portuguese and ancient Greek generally require the
> definite article with proper names; others like French only sometimes e.g.
> "la France".
which just means a person named John Smith. This is independent of whether
they take articles or not: in English, Manhattan is as definite as the Bronx,
and Terra is as definite as the Moon.