[YG Conlang Archives] > [saweli group] > messages [Date Index] [Thread Index] >

[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next]

ditransitive verbs: he called me a friend

In a message dated 5/13/2007 1:10:20 PM Central Daylight Time, sts@hidden.email writes:


you made me think and remember an old issue of saweli (since when it
used to be katanda). my "stupid" question has always been: how should
one adequately say "he called me a friend". i think i have a solution
now, and i would like to know what you think of it.

the part of the sentence "he called me" (or "he named me", "he labeled
me") actually changes it's part of speech from "sentence" to
"preposition". "a friend" is the argument of this preposition.

(end of solution)

nonetheless, "he called me a friend" is an entire sentence, even though
it is "just" a prepositional phrase. the transitive word "called" is
marked to be the root of the sentence, and this fact remains even though
the sentence may be linked with other sentences by conjunctions, or - in
this case - to the argument "a friend".


I think it could be a regular A/P/F verb, where "he" is A, "me" is P, and "a friend" is F.  But I tend to think it would be better to use a case tag meaning "being, as" or just a secondary P or F.  I'll have to look through ram's lessons to see if he has any such examples.  

I remember you bringing this up before.  We never reached a consensus at the time.

stevo